Echo House is a really interesting concept. It tells the story of a mother who had a son at 15 who is subsequently adopted, and they are estranged from one another for 50 years. From that simple premise spin out a myriad of different trajectories and outcomes based on suggestions from the audience and inspired by a series of improvisational games.
The title Echo House perfectly evokes the sense that a house contains layered incarnations, almost ghosts, of its occupants, their lives and the different directions they could have developed. And as people return to the house, the memories of actions past echo back to them in truthful and in misremembered ways. It’s ultimately left up to the audience to decide which version of the story is most true or 'best'.
The kaleidoscope of versions of this troubled mother-son relationship is immediately intriguing as a dramatic structure. With each passing scene the you are asked to reconsider whether the son is welcoming or unwelcoming, and whether the mother is delighted or anxious at the prospect of meeting her son after half a century apart. You’re even asked to consider the drastic possibility that one or other of them may have died by (depending on your audience) suicide, fork in the toaster, car accident or Wallaby kick!
This experimental way of storytelling is in its early stages of development for The Two Jays, a writing and performing duo made up of John Harper and Julia Bolden. Harper is a towering presence whose charming smile counteracts his imposing frame. Bolden is much shorter, a contrast which they jovially play for laughs, and her laid-back demeanour brings a relaxed, chilled energy.
At present while the opening scene carries a lot of exciting dramatic potential, the following scenes lack momentum and drive. The improvisational games don’t make enough of the audience suggestions. As we enter the auditorium, the audience are asked to write down suggestions which are put into a small wooden box to be used later in the show. The box is used during two monologues, by mother and son, but the suggestions are effectively just read out as a list. They're not used to change or develop the story. Furthermore, the only person who knows their suggestion has been read out is the person who wrote it because there's no wider sharing of what those suggestions are before the monologues take place.
Similarly, when we were asked whether we want the son to be welcoming or unwelcoming to his mother when she arrives at his front door, the audience resoundingly voted for welcoming and the scene was played out. But then the unwelcoming scene was played out as well. The audience suggestion turned out not be a decisive moment in the evening's narrative, but just a decision over which narrative we'd see first.
To make this show more powerful, the audience suggestions need to be more meaningful and impactful. They need to change the shape and direction of the story as a whole. If you shout stop in a scene as instructed or present a high or low status card it really has to make a difference to the way that scene plays out.
Overall an exciting concept in how to deliver a semi scripted, semi improvisational work, but it needs more trust in the audience suggestions to take flight.
Julia Bolden speaks eloquently about Echo House on a recent addition of my podcast What's On Watford which you can listen to here.